Stopping lunch shaming at school

LD 1684 bill text Read More MPA supported

Lunch shaming is a national problem. A 2014 report by the U.S. Department of Agriculture found that nearly half of all school districts used some form of it to pressure parents to pay. Thirty-nine percent of schools reported withholding the hot lunch and providing an “alternate meal,” such as a cold cheese sandwich, while three percent denied the child food entirely.

“If our students are hungry, they cannot learn. We must first take care of our students’ most basic needs in order to be able to provide them a quality education. I’ve heard heartbreaking stories from across the state where children are hungry and food is being thrown away…that must change. I wish we didn’t need to legislate feeding hungry children. But if even one child in our community is denied food, or humiliated because of a parent’s negligence, we need to do something.”
– Testimony by Lois Kilby-Chesley , president of the Maine Education Association President

What is the bill

This bill would have prohibited public schools from punishing, identifying, or stigmatizing a student who cannot pay for a meal or have meal payments due in cases where the family does not already qualify for free or reduced lunches. It mandates that schools discuss payment issues directly with the parent rather than use school children as go-betweens.

Why it matters

No child should have to go hungry. Maine has the third highest rate of hunger in the nation, while one in every five children in our state are food insecure. Food is a basic right, and all children should be served school meals whether parents can or cannot afford to pay. Furthermore, the embarrassment of being singled out and sometimes having to wear an identifying stamp or wristband is a form of punishment no child should have to endure.

What happened

PASSED BUT NOT ENACTED: This bill passed the House; at the time of publication, it has been “carried over” to a special session but hasn’t yet been heard by the Senate.

Votes

Democrat–Kittery
MPA bill stance
Supported
Rykerson vote
Supported
Democrat–Eliot
MPA bill stance
Supported
Lawrence vote
Supported
Democrat–York
MPA bill stance
Supported
Blume vote
Supported
Democrat–York
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hymanson vote
Supported
Republican–Berwick
MPA bill stance
Supported
O'Connor vote
Opposed
Democrat–South Berwick
MPA bill stance
Supported
Parker vote
Supported
Republican–Wells
MPA bill stance
Supported
Foley vote
Opposed
Democrat–Kennebunk
MPA bill stance
Supported
Babbidge vote
Supported
Republican–Kennebunkport
MPA bill stance
Supported
Seavey vote
Opposed
Republican–Arundel
MPA bill stance
Supported
Parry vote
Opposed
Democrat–Biddeford
MPA bill stance
Supported
Fecteau vote
Supported
Independent–Biddeford
MPA bill stance
Supported
Grohman vote
Supported
Democrat–Old Orchard Beach
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hogan vote
Supported
Democrat–Saco
MPA bill stance
Supported
Bailey vote
Supported
MPA bill stance
Supported
O'Neil vote
Supported
Republican–Hollis
MPA bill stance
Supported
Marean vote
Opposed
Republican–Waterboro
MPA bill stance
Supported
Prescott vote
Opposed
Democrat–Sanford
MPA bill stance
Supported
Mastraccio vote
Supported
Republican–Sanford
MPA bill stance
Supported
Harrington vote
Opposed
Republican–Lebanon
MPA bill stance
Supported
Gerrish vote
Opposed
Republican–Alfred
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sampson vote
Opposed
Republican–Limington
MPA bill stance
Supported
Kinney vote
Opposed
Republican–Standish
MPA bill stance
Supported
Ordway vote
Opposed
Democrat–Windham
MPA bill stance
Supported
Bryant vote
Supported
Republican–Windham
MPA bill stance
Supported
Corey vote
Opposed
MPA bill stance
Supported
Terry vote
Supported
Democrat–Gorham
MPA bill stance
Supported
McLean vote
Supported
Republican–Scarborough
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sirocki vote
Opposed
Republican–Scarborough
MPA bill stance
Supported
Vachon vote
Opposed
Democrat–Cape Elizabeth
MPA bill stance
Supported
Monaghan vote
Supported
Democrat–South Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Reckitt vote
Supported
Democrat–South Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hamann vote
Absent
Independent–South Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Battle vote
Supported
Democrat–Westbrook
MPA bill stance
Supported
Gattine vote
Supported
Democrat–Westbrook
MPA bill stance
Supported
Bates vote
Supported
Independent–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Harlow vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Farnsworth vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Moonen vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sylvester vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Ross vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Jorgensen vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Collings vote
Supported
Democrat–Portland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sanborn vote
Supported
Democrat–Falmouth
MPA bill stance
Supported
Pierce vote
Supported
Democrat–Cumberland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Denno vote
Supported
Republican–Durham
MPA bill stance
Supported
Chace vote
Opposed
Democrat–Yarmouth
MPA bill stance
Supported
Cooper vote
Supported
Democrat–Freeport
MPA bill stance
Supported
Gideon vote
Supported
MPA bill stance
Supported
Daughtry vote
Supported
Democrat–Brunswick
MPA bill stance
Supported
Tucker vote
Supported
Democrat–Harpswell
MPA bill stance
Supported
McCreight vote
Supported
MPA bill stance
Supported
DeChant vote
Supported
Republican–Dresden
MPA bill stance
Supported
Pierce vote
Opposed
Democrat–Topsham
MPA bill stance
Supported
Tepler vote
Supported
Democrat–Bowdoinham
MPA bill stance
Supported
Berry vote
Supported
Republican–Lisbon
MPA bill stance
Supported
Mason vote
Opposed
Republican–Greene
MPA bill stance
Supported
Wood vote
Opposed
Democrat–Lewiston
MPA bill stance
Supported
Handy vote
Supported
Democrat–Lewiston
MPA bill stance
Supported
Fuller vote
Supported
Democrat–Lewiston
MPA bill stance
Supported
Golden vote
Supported
Democrat–Lewiston
MPA bill stance
Supported
Brooks vote
Supported
Democrat–Auburn
MPA bill stance
Supported
Melaragno vote
Supported
Republican–Auburn
MPA bill stance
Supported
Bickford vote
Opposed
Democrat–Auburn
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sheats vote
Supported
Republican–New Gloucester
MPA bill stance
Supported
Espling vote
Opposed
Democrat–Raymond
MPA bill stance
Supported
Fay vote
Supported
Republican–Gray
MPA bill stance
Supported
Austin vote
Opposed
Republican–Naples
MPA bill stance
Supported
Cebra vote
Opposed
Republican–Bridgton
MPA bill stance
Supported
Ginzler vote
Opposed
Republican–Hiram
MPA bill stance
Supported
Wadsworth vote
Opposed
Republican–Norway
MPA bill stance
Supported
Winsor vote
Opposed
MPA bill stance
Supported
Dillingham vote
Opposed
Republican–Paris
MPA bill stance
Supported
Herrick vote
Opposed
Democrat–Jay
MPA bill stance
Supported
Riley vote
Supported
Republican–Turner
MPA bill stance
Supported
Timberlake vote
Opposed
Republican–Belgrade
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hilliard vote
Opposed
Republican–Oakland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Perkins vote
Opposed
Democrat–Winslow
MPA bill stance
Supported
Nadeau vote
Supported
Republican–China
MPA bill stance
Supported
Theriault vote
Opposed
Republican–Vassalboro
MPA bill stance
Supported
Bradstreet vote
Opposed
Democrat–Winthrop
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hickman vote
Supported
Common Sense Independent–Monmouth
MPA bill stance
Supported
Ackley vote
Supported
Democrat–Gardiner
MPA bill stance
Supported
Grant vote
Supported
Democrat–Hallowell
MPA bill stance
Supported
Warren vote
Supported
Democrat–Augusta
MPA bill stance
Supported
Doore vote
Supported
Republican–Augusta
MPA bill stance
Supported
Pouliot vote
Supported
Republican–Pittston
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hanley vote
Opposed
Republican–Chelsea
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sanderson vote
Opposed
Republican–Boothbay Harbor
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hawke vote
Opposed
Democrat–Newcastle
MPA bill stance
Supported
Devin vote
Supported
Republican–Waldoboro
MPA bill stance
Supported
Simmons vote
Opposed
Democrat–South Thomaston
MPA bill stance
Supported
Spear vote
Opposed
Democrat–Rockland
MPA bill stance
Supported
Beebe-Center vote
Supported
Independent–Rockport
MPA bill stance
Supported
Casás vote
Supported
Republican–Warren
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sutton vote
Opposed
MPA bill stance
Supported
Zeigler vote
Supported
Democrat–Belfast
MPA bill stance
Supported
Herbig vote
Supported
Republican–Searsport
MPA bill stance
Supported
Gillway vote
Opposed
Republican–Knox
MPA bill stance
Supported
Kinney vote
Opposed
Republican–Newport
MPA bill stance
Supported
Fredette vote
Opposed
Republican–Hampden
MPA bill stance
Supported
Haggan vote
Opposed
Republican–Glenburn
MPA bill stance
Supported
Guerin vote
Opposed
Republican–Carmel
MPA bill stance
Supported
Reed vote
Opposed
Republican–Dexter
MPA bill stance
Supported
Wallace vote
Opposed
Republican–Canaan
MPA bill stance
Supported
Stetkis vote
Opposed
Republican–Pittsfield
MPA bill stance
Supported
Strom vote
Supported
Democrat–Skowhegan
MPA bill stance
Supported
Austin vote
Supported
Republican–Fairfield
MPA bill stance
Supported
Picchiotti vote
Opposed
Democrat–Waterville
MPA bill stance
Supported
Longstaff vote
Supported
Democrat–Waterville
MPA bill stance
Supported
Madigan vote
Supported
Republican–Norridgewock
MPA bill stance
Supported
Farrin vote
Opposed
Republican–Weld
MPA bill stance
Supported
Skolfield vote
Opposed
Republican–Farmington
MPA bill stance
Supported
Harvell vote
Opposed
Republican–Wilton
MPA bill stance
Supported
Black vote
Absent
Democrat–Rumford
MPA bill stance
Supported
Madigan vote
Supported
Republican–Dixfield
MPA bill stance
Supported
Pickett vote
Opposed
Republican–Bethel
MPA bill stance
Supported
Head vote
Absent
Republican–Athens
MPA bill stance
Supported
Grignon vote
Opposed
Republican–Guilford
MPA bill stance
Supported
Stearns vote
Opposed
Independent–Dover-Foxcroft
MPA bill stance
Supported
Higgins vote
Supported
Democrat–Hudson
MPA bill stance
Supported
Duchesne vote
Supported
Democrat–Old Town
MPA bill stance
Supported
Dunphy vote
Supported
Democrat–Orono
MPA bill stance
Supported
Tipping vote
Supported
Democrat–Bangor
MPA bill stance
Supported
Frey vote
Supported
MPA bill stance
Supported
Kornfield vote
Supported
Democrat–Bangor
MPA bill stance
Supported
Schneck vote
Supported
Democrat–Bangor
MPA bill stance
Supported
Cardone vote
Supported
Republican–Brewer
MPA bill stance
Supported
Craig vote
Opposed
Republican–Eddington
MPA bill stance
Supported
Lyford vote
Opposed
Republican–Orrington
MPA bill stance
Supported
Campbell vote
Opposed
Republican–Dedham
MPA bill stance
Supported
Ward vote
Supported
Democrat–Ellsworth
MPA bill stance
Supported
Luchini vote
Supported
Green Independent–Brooksville
MPA bill stance
Supported
Chapman vote
Supported
Democrat–Deer Isle
MPA bill stance
Supported
Kumiega vote
Supported
Democrat–Bar Harbor
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hubbell vote
Supported
Republican–Hancock
MPA bill stance
Supported
Malaby vote
Opposed
Republican–Amherst
MPA bill stance
Supported
Lockman vote
Opposed
MPA bill stance
Supported
Alley vote
Supported
Republican–East Machias
MPA bill stance
Supported
Tuell vote
Supported
Democrat–Calais
MPA bill stance
Supported
Perry vote
Supported
Republican–Burlington
MPA bill stance
Supported
Turner vote
Opposed
Republican–Lincoln
MPA bill stance
Supported
Hanington vote
Opposed
Democrat–Medway
MPA bill stance
Supported
Stanley vote
Supported
Republican–Hodgdon
MPA bill stance
Supported
Sherman vote
Absent
Republican–Monticello
MPA bill stance
Supported
Johansen vote
Opposed
Republican–Washburn
MPA bill stance
Supported
White vote
Opposed
Republican–Presque Isle
MPA bill stance
Supported
Stewart vote
Opposed
Democrat–Fort Fairfield
MPA bill stance
Supported
McCrea vote
Supported
Republican–Caribou
MPA bill stance
Supported
McElwee vote
Opposed
Democrat–Sinclair
MPA bill stance
Supported
Martin vote
Supported
Democrat–Eagle Lake
MPA bill stance
Supported
Martin vote
Supported